A short exercise

The guilt curve.

Most of us have said no and then spent the evening feeling that we did something wrong. The guilt arrives quickly, it feels very large, and many of us read it as a sign that the no was a mistake. Far fewer of us have watched what the feeling does over a few minutes, or noticed that feeling guilty and wanting to take the no back are two different things.

This exercise asks you two questions straight after a no, then asks them again every minute for about four minutes: how guilty do you feel, and how much do you want to take the no back? It draws your two answers as lines, so you can see your own feeling move, or not move, and see whether the two lines are the same size. It does not tell you whether to keep the no. It shows you what the feeling does while you wait.

From the field note Getting to the no is the hard part: how to then say no without feeling guilty. New here? Read it first, or just start below.

How to use it

  1. Start straight after you have said no, or when the guilt is loudest. Think of one no you have just said, or one you said today, and type it in a few words if you like, for example “I said no to hosting again this year” or “I turned down the extra project”. Say it as something you decided, so you are looking at the guilt about your own no and not at the person who asked. You can leave the box empty.
  2. Give your first two numbers, then wait. Choose a number from 0 to 10 for how guilty you feel right now, and a number from 0 to 10 for how much you want to take the no back. 0 is not at all and 10 is as much as you have ever felt. Then leave the page open. About a minute later it will ask you again, up to five times in all. For some people the guilt lands as a feeling in the body, a tight chest or a heavy stomach. For others it lands as a thought that says you were wrong. Either is fine. Give the number that is true for you right now, not the number you think it should be.
  3. Read your two lines. After the fifth reading, or when you press Stop here, you will see your guilt and your wish to take the no back drawn side by side, with a short sentence about what each one did. The important bit for this exercise is to look at the two lines separately. Your guilt can be high while your wish to take the no back stays low, and that is worth knowing. If your lines stayed flat or went up, that is a real result too. Four minutes is short, and feelings can take anything from seconds to hours to change.

It takes about five minutes. Nothing you type or choose is saved or sent anywhere, and it is gone when you close or refresh the page.

Step 1 of 3

Name the no in the box below, or leave it empty. Then choose how guilty you feel right now and how much you want to take the no back, and press Start.

0 of 120 characters

Step 2 of 3

Step 3 of 3

Here are your two lines. The solid line is how guilty you felt. The dashed line is how much you wanted to take the no back. Read each one separately. You can copy your numbers, or start again.

Did the feeling change what you decided?

This is a way of looking at a feeling, not a test of it. If this is more than guilt, or you feel unsafe, please talk to someone near you or to a local helpline.

More on the wording of the no itself: A clean no.

Cut the no back before you send it: the clean no checker.

If the yes keeps coming out before you can stop it: how to stop people-pleasing.

Read the field note: Getting to the no is the hard part: how to then say no without feeling guilty.

If you would like someone alongside you for the guilt that follows a no, I keep a free 45-minute call open.

Book a Discovery Call

Get new pieces by email

Occasional, when something is worth sending. No schedule to keep up with.

Unsubscribe any time.